4 spice protein shake Recipes

water or 3/4 cup milk, pumpkin puree, vanilla protein powder (1 scoop), sugar-free vanilla syrup, pumpkin pie spice, splenda sugar substitute, half-and-half, ice cube

sugar-free instant vanilla pudding mix (just says pudding), skim milk (just says milk) or 1 cup 1% low-fat milk (just says milk), vanilla protein powder (2 scoops) or 2 -4 tbsp unflavored protein powder (2 scoops), canned pumpkin (canned not pumpkin pie), pumpkin pie spice

unsweetened pumpkin puree, spenda sugar substitute, salt, cinnamon, ginger, scant ), milk or 1 cup soy, matrix vanilla protein powder (1 scoop), sugar cool whip free or 1/4 cup no sugar added vanilla ice cream, ice, sugar free cinnamon bliss caramel sauce (optional)