1. Toast the marshmallows to your liking. Choose from the following variations. 2. The Classic: Sandwich the toasted marshmallows and chocolate bars between classic graham crackers. 3. The Peppermint: Sandwich the toasted marshmallows and peppermint patties between chocolate graham crackers. 4. The Peanut Butter: Sandwich the toasted marshmallows and peanut butter cups between chocolate or classic graham crackers. 5. Cook's Note: You may wrap the s'mores individually in pieces of foil and bake them in a 325 degree F oven until the ingredients are warm and melted.